Skip to content

Simulation and role-play · Guide

AI Simulations in Higher Education: Types, Uses and How to Start

By The Rocketproof TeamPublished Updated 5 min read
On this page

What counts as an AI simulation#

Higher education has used simulation for a long time: mock trials, clinical labs, business games, tabletop exercises. An AI simulation uses a language model to play some part of the situation. Depending on the design, the model may play a person the student talks with, or it may narrate what happens as the student decides what to do.

Three types are in common use.

  1. Conversational simulation. The student has an open conversation with an AI character, such as a patient or a client. The student chooses what to say. This is the format most people mean by AI role-play. See what AI role-play is.
  2. Branching scenario. The student faces a situation, makes a decision, and the next situation depends on that decision. The student is often asked to justify each choice. AI can generate or adapt the situations.
  3. Guided conversation. A conversation with a defined scenario, a goal and rules for when it ends, such as "the student has gathered the required information" or "ten minutes have passed." The structure keeps sessions comparable across students.

The three can be combined, and an instructor can start with whichever matches the outcome.

When a simulation is the right tool#

Use a simulation when the outcome is about doing something in a situation that involves another party or a changing context. Examples include interviewing, negotiating, advising, triaging, de-escalating and making decisions under uncertainty. Use something else when the outcome is purely factual recall, when the skill needs physical practice, or when the situation cannot be represented well through conversation.

A useful check: could you observe the skill if you sat beside the student in a real situation? If yes, a simulation might give you a similar observation at scale.

Formative and summative simulation#

The same scenario can serve two different purposes, and the design differs.

Formative simulationSummative simulation
PurposeHelp students improveProduce evidence for a grade
Counts toward the gradeNoYes
AttemptsManyUsually one, with a planned retake policy
FeedbackImmediate and detailedAfter review by the instructor
RubricShared as a guideApplied consistently and shared in advance
Stakes for the studentLowHigher, so accommodations and appeals matter
Instructor reviewSpot checksRequired for every graded attempt

A common pattern is to give students unlimited practice attempts and then one graded attempt on a parallel scenario. Black and Wiliam's review of formative assessment supports the value of feedback during learning, and Ericsson and colleagues' account of deliberate practice supports repeated attempts with feedback.

Discipline examples#

Planning a first pilot#

  1. Choose one outcome that is hard to observe now. Pick a skill where students currently get little practice.
  2. Write the scenario and the rubric together. The rubric tells you what evidence the scenario has to produce. The design guide explains how.
  3. Test the scenario yourself. Run it five or six times, play difficult students, and note where the AI breaks character or gives away answers.
  4. Run a small group. Ask students what felt realistic and what did not.
  5. Review the transcripts. Read a sample. Check that the scores you would give match the evidence.
  6. Decide on practice and graded use. Start with practice unless you have a clear plan for accommodations and appeals.
  7. Plan for access. Offer a text option and an alternative for students who cannot use voice.
  8. Review privacy. Confirm retention, access and whether the vendor trains models on student data.

The blog essay on AI role-play simulations for higher education walks through a small pilot in more detail.

Risks and guardrails#

  • Realism is not accuracy. An AI character may state facts that are wrong. Provide reference material and test for consistency.
  • Bias. Characters may reproduce stereotypes. Read transcripts for them.
  • Student wellbeing. Some scenarios, such as a distressed patient or a conflict, can be upsetting. Brief students and give them a way to stop.
  • Overstating what the evidence shows. A transcript shows what a student said in a simulated setting. Say so.
  • Academic integrity. Students can have help during a take-home simulation. If the stakes are high, consider supervised sessions.
  • Human judgment. A person should decide the grade.

Measuring whether it works#

Compare, before and after, the thing you care about. That might be rubric scores on a later in-person performance, supervisor ratings in placements, or the quality of reflection. Keep records of how many attempts each student made and what changed between them. Avoid conclusions from a single cohort.

Where Rocketproof.ai fits#

Rocketproof.ai supports conversational role-play, branching scenarios and guided conversations in which the instructor defines the persona, the goal and the completion rules. A conversation can be marked as practice and kept out of the gradebook, or graded with a rubric. Students can respond by voice or text, and the instructor reviews the transcript and draft scores before a grade is released. The AI simulations page has examples, and the platform comparison places it beside other products.

Frequently asked questions

What is an AI simulation in education?
A designed scenario in which students talk with an AI character or make a series of decisions, to practice or demonstrate professional skills in a realistic situation.
Can AI simulations be used for assessment?
Yes. A simulation can be graded against a rubric, and the transcript records the student's decisions and reasons. Plan accommodations, an appeal path and instructor review for graded use.
What is the difference between formative and summative simulation?
A formative simulation helps students improve and does not count toward the grade. A summative simulation produces evidence for a grade and needs consistent scoring and instructor review.
Can students practice with AI simulations before a graded attempt?
Yes. A common design is unlimited practice attempts, kept out of the gradebook, followed by one graded attempt on a parallel scenario.
Can AI simulations integrate with Canvas?
Tools that use LTI 1.3 can launch from a Canvas course and return grades. Ask each vendor to demonstrate the launch and the grade return.

Sources

  1. Black, P., & Wiliam, D. (1998). Assessment and classroom learning. Assessment in Education: Principles, Policy & Practice, 5(1). doi.org/10.1080/0969595980050102(opens in a new tab)
  2. Ericsson, K. A., Krampe, R. T., & Tesch-Römer, C. (1993). The role of deliberate practice in the acquisition of expert performance. Psychological Review, 100(3). doi.org/10.1037/0033-295X.100.3.363(opens in a new tab)

The Rocketproof Team

Rocketproof.ai builds assessment and simulation software for higher education.

Found an error or a missing source? Tell us.

Try it with your own course in mind

The interactive demo needs no account. It shows what a student does and what the instructor reviews afterward.